| Nr. | Spieler | Pos. | College/Uni/Team | Geburtsdatum | Gestorben |
| 1. | Art Allison | Outfielder, 1. Baseman | Undrafted | 26. Januear 1849 | 25. Februar 1916 |
| 2. | John Bass | Shortstop Outfielder, Catcher | Undrafted | 22. Juli 1948 | 25. September 1888 |
| 3. | Joe Battin | 3rd Baseman 2nd Baseman | Undrafted | 11. November 1854 | 10. Dezember 1937 |
| 4. | Jim Carlton | 1st Baseman | Undfrafted | 20. August 1848 | 25. April 1910 |
| 5. | George Ewell | Rightfielder | Undrafted | 29. Oktober 1850 | 20. Oktober 1910 |
| 6. | William Johnson | 2nd Baseman Rightfielder | Undrafted | 1. Juni 1848 | 25. September 1909 |
| 7. | Gene Kimball | 2nd Baseman Rightfielder Shortstop | Undrafted | 31. August 1850 | 2. August 1882 |
| 8. | Charlie Pabor | Leftfielder Pitcher | Undrafted | 24. September 1846 | 23. April 1913 |
| 9. | Al Pratt | Pitcher Outfielder | Undrafted | 19. November 1847 | 21. November 1937 |
| 10. | Joe Quest | 2nd Baseman Shortstop | Undrafted | 16. November 1852 | 14. November 1924 |
| 11. | Ezra Sutton | 3rd Baseman Shortstop Outfielder | Undrafted | 17. September 1849 | 20. Juni 1907 |
| 12. | Elmer White | Rightfielder Catcher | Undrafted | 07. Dezember 1849 | 17. März 1872 |
| 13. | Deacon White | 3rd Baseman Catcher Rightfielder | Undradted | 02. Dezember 1847 | 07. Juli 1939 |