| Nr. | Spieler | Pos. | College/Uni | Geburtsdatum | Gestorben |
| 1. | Robert Armstrong | Centerfielder | Undrafted | 04. Juli 1850 | 03. Dezember 1917 |
| 2. | Bill Barrett | Catcher 3rd Baseman Shortstop | Undrafted | ? | ? |
| 3. | Charles Bierman | 1st Baseman | Undrafted | 1845 | 04. August 1879 |
| Nr. | Spieler | Pos. | College/Uni | Geburtsdatum | Gestorben |
| 1. | Robert Armstrong | Centerfielder | Undrafted | 04. Juli 1850 | 03. Dezember 1917 |
| 2. | Bill Barrett | Catcher 3rd Baseman Shortstop | Undrafted | ? | ? |
| 3. | Charles Bierman | 1st Baseman | Undrafted | 1845 | 04. August 1879 |